Connect with us

Politics

WHEN PRIVACY BECOMES CONTENT: The Dangerous Normalisation of Leaked Private Conversations

Published

on

Senator Akpabio and Sandra C. Duru
Spread the love

By Ken Harries, Esq.

There is a point at which political contestation ceases to be an argument about ideas and becomes an assault on the very boundaries that make civil society possible. That point is reached when a private telephone conversation is allegedly recorded, extracted from its original context and released into the public domain as political ammunition.

The latest controversy surrounding an audio recording purported to be a telephone conversation between Senator Godswill Akpabio and Sandra C. Duru, a.k.a. Professor Mgbeke, therefore deserves to be examined beyond the personalities involved. It raises a much larger question: What happens to a society when private conversations become raw material for public propaganda?

Recent reports indicate that Sandra Duru released a nine-minute audio recording on social media and presented portions of it as a private conversation involving the Senate President. Yet, significantly, the recording has not been independently authenticated, and questions remain about the identity of the voices, the circumstances in which the conversation was recorded, and whether the excerpts constitute the complete conversation. Those uncertainties are not minor technicalities; they are at the heart of responsible public communication.

Maduka College Advert

PRIVACY IS NOT A POLITICAL LUXURY

Nigeria’s Constitution is unequivocal in recognising privacy as a fundamental right. Section 37 guarantees and protects the privacy of citizens, including their homes, correspondence and telephone conversations. That constitutional safeguard does not disappear because the individuals involved are politicians, public officials, activists or controversial personalities. Indeed, public office should never be interpreted as a wholesale surrender of personal privacy.

The Nigeria Data Protection Act 2023 reinforces this principle by establishing a legal framework for protecting personal information and regulating its processing. Among its stated objectives are the protection of fundamental rights and freedoms, the safeguarding of personal data, and the requirement that personal data be processed in a fair, lawful and accountable manner.

The central question, therefore, is not whether an audio recording can generate political excitement; it obviously can. The question is whether private communication can be captured, processed, edited, reproduced and disseminated for political purposes without lawful justification, proper authorisation or regard for the rights of the people whose voices and personal information are involved. That is a much more serious question.

THE CYBER DIMENSION CANNOT BE IGNORED

The Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act, as amended in 2024, also contains provisions concerning unlawful interception of non-public computer communications and judicially authorised interception of electronic communications. The legislation defines interception broadly enough to include listening to or recording communication data in specified circumstances. But legal precision matters, particularly when criminal liability is being discussed.

It would be premature for commentators to declare, without establishing the facts, that the mere existence or publication of this particular audio automatically constitutes a criminal offence under the Cybercrimes Act. If, however, the evidence establishes that a private electronic communication was intercepted or obtained without lawful authority, the circumstances could raise serious questions under the applicable constitutional, data-protection and cybercrime frameworks. That is precisely why an independent investigation matters: the law should determine the legality, not social media.

PUBLIC INTEREST IS NOT A BLANK CHEQUE

There is another important distinction that the Nigerian public must begin to make. A matter involving a public official may be of public interest without every private conversation involving that official becoming public property. Public interest is not the same thing as public curiosity.

A genuine public-interest disclosure ordinarily requires more than the ability to attract clicks, outrage or political engagement. It requires consideration of authenticity, context, provenance, relevance and the legitimate rights of the people involved. A fragment of an alleged private conversation, detached from the circumstances in which it occurred and presented to millions of people without independent authentication, can easily become something very different from responsible whistleblowing.

It can become narrative engineering, particularly when selected material is used to encourage the public towards a predetermined interpretation. When such narrative engineering is repeatedly used to shape public perception, it begins to resemble propaganda rather than public accountability.

THE MORAL QUESTION

There is also a moral dimension that no statute can completely capture. Politics is already a theatre of suspicion, rivalry and competing narratives. If every private conversation is potentially a future weapon, trust disappears from public life. People stop speaking candidly, officials become afraid of legitimate conversations, and citizens become unwilling to engage public figures.

Political communication then gradually degenerates into a marketplace where the most sensational fragment—not necessarily the most truthful account—commands the greatest attention. This is where the conduct surrounding the dissemination of private conversations raises profound ethical questions.

A society that normalises the conversion of private conversations into political weapons risks producing a culture in which nothing is private, context is disposable and reputation is collateral damage. That is not democratic accountability; it is the erosion of the ethical architecture upon which democratic accountability depends.

THE PROBLEM WITH THE “MERCHANT OF PROPAGANDA” MODEL

There is a growing phenomenon in digital politics in which controversy itself becomes a political commodity. The objective is no longer necessarily to establish facts, but to generate a continuous stream of allegations, recordings, screenshots, insinuations and counter-allegations until the public becomes emotionally exhausted and truth becomes indistinguishable from repetition.

The danger is particularly acute when the communicator becomes both the source of the allegation and the narrator of the evidence. That model creates an obvious credibility problem because the public is effectively being asked to accept not merely the allegation but also the interpretation supplied by the person disseminating it.

That is why independent verification is indispensable. A recording should be authenticated, its provenance established, its full context examined and any editing disclosed. The circumstances of its acquisition should also be investigated. Where there are allegations of unlawful interception or misuse of personal data, the appropriate regulatory and law-enforcement authorities should be allowed to do their work.

FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION HAS RESPONSIBILITIES

Freedom of expression is indispensable to democracy, but so is the right to privacy. These principles should not be presented as enemies. Responsible journalism, legitimate whistleblowing and public-interest disclosure have their place, but none of them should become convenient labels for every unauthorised exposure of private communications.

The democratic answer to disputed conduct is evidence, investigation and due process—not digital vigilantism. If the recording is authentic and contains evidence of wrongdoing, the proper response is to submit the evidence to the appropriate institutions and allow the facts to be tested. If it is unauthorised, manipulated, selectively edited or misleadingly presented, those facts should also be established through proper investigation. Either way, the truth deserves a process more rigorous than a Facebook post.

THIS IS BIGGER THAN AKPABIO

The most important lesson from this episode should not be about Senator Godswill Akpabio alone; it should be about the Nigeria we are creating. Today, it may be a conversation involving a Senate President. Tomorrow, it could be a judge, journalist, businessman, civil servant, academic, clergy member or ordinary citizen.

If the principle becomes that anyone who possesses a private recording is entitled to publish it whenever politically convenient, then privacy ceases to be a right and becomes merely a temporary privilege enjoyed by those who have not yet been recorded. That is a dangerous trend with implications extending far beyond the personalities involved in the present controversy.

The constitutional guarantee of privacy cannot be selectively defended, data protection cannot become a slogan deployed only when convenient, and cybercrime legislation cannot be invoked selectively. Political communication cannot be allowed to become a free-for-all in which reputations are tried and convicted on social media before evidence is examined.

LET THE LAW SPEAK

There is, therefore, a compelling case for the relevant authorities to establish the facts surrounding any purported private telephone recording now circulating. Who made the recording? How was it obtained? Was consent given? Was the communication intercepted? Was it edited? Who first disseminated it, and for what purpose? What personal data were processed? Was there a lawful basis for that processing? And does the dissemination violate any applicable constitutional, statutory or judicial protection? Those are questions for evidence, not conjecture.

There is, however, a broader principle worth defending: private communication should not become political ammunition merely because it can generate attention. A democracy requires trust, evidence, restraint and respect for the law. Public accountability is strengthened, not weakened, when allegations are subjected to verification and established processes rather than determined by the velocity of social-media circulation.

The real moral deficit in contemporary public discourse is not that people disagree. It is that the boundaries between legitimate scrutiny and intrusion can become dangerously blurred when private material is circulated without adequate attention to authenticity, context, provenance and applicable law. Once society becomes indifferent to those boundaries, everyone—not merely public officials—has reason to be concerned about the future of privacy.

• Ken Harries, Esq., is an Abuja-based Development Communication Strategist.

Politics

Umeh Apologises to Anambra People for Supporting Soludo’s Emergence as Governor

Published

on

Governor Soludo and Senator Umeh
Spread the love

Senator representing Anambra Central, Victor Umeh, has apologised to the people of Anambra State for his role in the emergence of Governor Chukwuma Soludo, saying he deeply regrets supporting his election.

Umeh tendered the apology in Awka on Thursday, expressing disappointment with Soludo’s leadership and accusing him of working against the political interests of Anambra State and the wider Igbo nation.

The senator recalled that he served as Director-General of Soludo’s first governorship campaign alongside other prominent political figures, including Chief Primus Odili, who served as Chief of Staff to former Governor Willie Obiano.

He said he and other members of the campaign team worked tirelessly to secure Soludo’s victory, disclosing that the governor personally approached him during the campaign to seek financial assistance after admitting that he lacked the resources to prosecute the election.

Maduka College Advert

According to Umeh, he subsequently contacted wealthy Anambra indigenes to raise funds for the campaign, with three prominent industrialists responding with donations of N1 billion, N100 million and $100,000, respectively.

He further alleged that the N1 billion contribution made by one of the businessmen had yet to be refunded, although he maintained that the outstanding money was not his major source of disappointment.

Rather, Umeh said his greatest concern was Soludo’s opposition to the presidential ambition of former Anambra State Governor, Peter Obi.

The senator accused Soludo of acting against the interests of his people by opposing Obi, arguing that the governor’s position amounted to working against the political aspirations of Anambra State and the wider Igbo nation.

Expressing regret over his role in Soludo’s emergence, Umeh said he never imagined that the governor would turn out the way he has.

“I am sorry for bringing him. I did not know he would turn out like this.

“Soludo is working against Ndigbo. You can’t be the governor of Anambra State and work against its interests,” he said.

Continue Reading

Politics

State Police: Yilwatda hails unanimous endorsement by 36 State Assemblies, governors

Published

on

The National Chairman, All Progressives Congress, Prof Nentawe Yilwatda. Photo: APC
Spread the love

•  APC chairman says Tinubu is building a safer Nigeria, urges continuity ahead of 2027 presidential election

The National Chairman of the All Progressives Congress (APC), Prof. Nentawe Goshwe Yilwatda, has commended the 36 state governors and all 36 State Houses of Assembly for their unanimous support for the proposed constitutional amendment to establish State Police Services in Nigeria.

Yilwatda described the development as a landmark achievement in the country’s democratic evolution and a demonstration of political maturity, national consensus and constructive cooperation among the different tiers of government.

In a statement issued by his Special Adviser on Media and Information Strategy, Mr Abimbola Tooki, the APC chairman said the unanimous endorsement by the 36 State Houses of Assembly represented an unprecedented collective commitment to addressing one of Nigeria’s most pressing challenges: the security of lives and property.

Speaking during a meeting with party stakeholders in Abuja, Yilwatda particularly applauded the governors for their positive disposition, constructive engagement and support for the initiative.

Maduka College Advert

He also commended the Speakers and members of the various State Houses of Assembly for recognising the urgency and importance of the proposed security reform.

According to him, the willingness of all states, irrespective of political affiliations and differences, to support the constitutional amendment demonstrates that national security transcends partisan considerations and remains a collective responsibility.

“This development is a powerful affirmation that when the national interest is placed above political differences, our democratic institutions can work together to deliver meaningful solutions to the challenges confronting our country,” he said.

Yilwatda described the proposed establishment of State Police Services as a major component of President Bola Tinubu’s broader reform agenda aimed at building a more responsive, effective and practical security architecture for Nigeria.

He argued that the country’s security challenges had exposed the limitations of an overly centralised policing structure in responding adequately to the peculiar security realities of different communities and geographical locations.

According to him, State Police would provide an additional layer of policing, bringing security administration closer to the people and enabling authorities to respond more promptly to threats within their jurisdictions.

He said the proposed framework would give state governments greater institutional capacity to complement the Federal Police Service in crime prevention, intelligence gathering, maintenance of law and order, and protection of communities.

Among the anticipated benefits, he listed improved grassroots intelligence gathering, faster response to security emergencies, more effective community policing, better understanding of local security threats and stronger collaboration between federal and state security institutions.

He added that the reform would strengthen efforts to tackle kidnapping, banditry, communal violence, armed robbery, terrorism and other criminal activities threatening the safety and economic wellbeing of Nigerians.

“Most importantly, State Police will enhance the capacity of government to identify emerging security threats before they escalate into major security emergencies,” he said.

However, the APC chairman stressed that the success of the initiative must be anchored on professionalism, adequate training, accountability, respect for fundamental human rights and strict adherence to constitutional provisions.

He warned that State Police Services must be established to protect citizens and enforce the law, rather than serve as instruments of political intimidation or partisan interests.

Yilwatda also commended President Tinubu for what he described as his courage, determination and commitment to addressing the country’s security challenges through institutional reforms and practical solutions.

He said the President’s approach was driven by the understanding that the primary responsibility of government was the protection of lives and property and that every Nigerian deserved to live in safety, dignity and peace, irrespective of geographical location, ethnic background, religious affiliation or political persuasion.

“The President’s determination to advance the State Police initiative demonstrates his willingness to take difficult but necessary decisions in the overriding interest of national security,” he said.

Yilwatda maintained that security should not be treated as a privilege reserved for residents of particular cities or regions, insisting that Nigerians in metropolitan centres, rural communities, farming settlements and border towns all deserved adequate protection.

He expressed confidence that, with the necessary constitutional processes and implementation safeguards, the State Police framework would become an important instrument for strengthening national security and restoring public confidence in the country’s policing system.

The APC chairman further argued that the proposed State Police reform, alongside other ongoing institutional and economic reforms, underscored the need for continuity in leadership under President Tinubu.

He urged Nigerians to look beyond political rhetoric and assess the country’s direction based on the policies, decisions, institutional reforms and measurable commitments of the present administration.

According to him, nation-building requires courage, consistency, experience and the willingness to confront difficult challenges rather than abandon necessary reforms whenever they become politically inconvenient.

“Nigeria cannot afford to repeatedly interrupt its reform journey or return to the uncertainties of leadership approaches that have failed to deliver sustainable solutions to the country’s fundamental challenges,” he said.

As the country approaches the January 16, 2027 presidential election, Yilwatda called on Nigerians across the 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory to vote for President Tinubu’s re-election.

He said continuity would provide an opportunity to consolidate ongoing reforms, strengthen the security architecture, deepen economic recovery, improve infrastructure, expand opportunities for young Nigerians and build on the foundations already being established for a more prosperous country.

The APC chairman said the forthcoming election presented Nigerians with an important choice between sustaining an ongoing reform programme and embracing political alternatives whose records in public office should be critically assessed.

He cautioned Nigerians against entrusting the country’s future to political actors whose overriding ambition, according to him, was to occupy the highest political office rather than present credible, practical and sustainable solutions to national challenges.

Yilwatda noted that the ambition to become President did not, in itself, qualify anyone for leadership, stressing that what mattered was the capacity to lead, clarity of vision, courage to make difficult decisions and a demonstrable record of responsible governance.

“It would be dangerous for the country to surrender its future to individuals whose previous opportunities to serve in positions of authority did not produce the economic stability, institutional strength and national development they now promise Nigerians,” he said.

He further argued that some politicians seeking a return to power had been part of previous administrations whose economic policies and governance decisions contributed to the difficulties the country subsequently faced.

He urged Nigerians to critically examine the records of presidential aspirants by asking what they achieved when they had the opportunity to govern, the lasting institutions they built and the solutions they provided to the economic and security challenges of their time.

Yilwatda insisted that Nigeria’s future must not become an experiment in political nostalgia, personal ambition or desperation for power.

Continue Reading

Politics

2027: ADC Appeals Leadership Judgment, Seeks to Stop INEC from Dropping Atiku

Published

on

ADC Presidential candidate, Atiku Abubakar
Spread the love

The African Democratic Congress (ADC) has approached the Court of Appeal, seeking to overturn the judgment that nullified the leadership of the party led by former Senate President, David Mark.

The party is also asking the appellate court to restrain the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) from altering its leadership records or tampering with the names and nomination details of its presidential and governorship candidates pending the determination of its appeal.

The ADC argued that the judgment delivered by Justice Lifu was based on an amended court process that was already the subject of a pending appeal.

It faulted the trial court for delivering its ruling before the earlier appeal had been determined, describing the development as a matter requiring the intervention of the appellate court.

Maduka College Advert

According to the party, allowing INEC to implement the judgment at this stage could trigger changes that might be difficult to reverse, even if the appeal eventually succeeds.

The party is therefore seeking an order directing INEC to maintain the status quo that existed before the November 5 judgment, to safeguard its candidates’ participation in the 2027 general elections.

It urged the electoral commission to refrain from taking any action that could undermine the appellate court’s eventual decision or jeopardise the political interests of its candidates while the appeal and related applications remain pending.

The ADC further argued that the Court of Appeal must preserve the subject matter of the dispute to ensure that its eventual judgment is not rendered ineffective by any intervening action.

“These are serious questions before the Court of Appeal,” the party said.

Continue Reading

Trending

Maduka College Advert